Raised in Marion County, Florida · Live feeders ship Monday through Friday

Discoid Roaches vs Crickets: Why We Prefer Discoids

◆
Discoid roach (Blaberus discoidalis) and Acheta cricket (Acheta domesticus) facing each other on bark

Premium insect feeders, raised and fed with care. Better feeding begins with better choices.

Crickets have been a familiar part of reptile keeping for generations. They're widely recognized, readily accepted by many insect-eating reptiles, and have earned their place in the feeder world.

But familiar isn't the same as convenient.

At Reptile Feeder Insects, we believe feeding your reptiles should be simple, thoughtful and rewarding, not a constant battle with escaped crickets, unpleasant odors and insects that die before your reptiles have a chance to eat them.

That's why we've made discoid roaches (Blaberus discoidalis) one of our preferred live feeders. We still feed crickets on occasion. We simply believe discoids deserve a much bigger place on the reptile menu.

The trouble with crickets

Anyone who has kept a container of live crickets knows the experience. The chirping. The jumping. The smell. The cleaning.

And perhaps the most frustrating part: opening a container only to discover that some of the insects you paid for have already died.

Crickets require attentive husbandry. Poor ventilation, excess moisture, overcrowding, temperature swings and built-up waste can all contribute to losses.

For keepers who order feeders regularly, those losses add up. You're not only paying for the insects. You're paying for shipping, packaging and the effort of keeping them alive until feeding time. When part of an order dies early, the cost per usable feeder rises.

Meet the discoid roach

Discoid roaches offer reptile keepers a nutritious, practical alternative to crickets.

These tropical roaches are well suited to managed feeder colonies and can be kept in a ventilated container with suitable food, moisture and warmth.

Discoid roaches don't chirp. They also tend to be easier to contain in smooth-sided enclosures, although a secure lid and good husbandry are still essential.

No live feeder insect is entirely odor-free, but a well-kept discoid colony can be a welcome change for keepers tired of cricket containers.

How we feed our discoids

Premium insect feeders start with what the insects eat. Our discoids live in our Marion County, Florida colonies, where they get a species-appropriate diet plus leafy greens, fresh vegetables and squash. We don't use potatoes as the fresh-food base.

When we bring in new stock, it goes into our colonies and onto the same diet before it's offered for sale. A well-fed feeder is a better meal for your reptile.

Learn more about how we raise our feeders

What about nutrition?

Nutrition matters far more than the popularity of any particular feeder insect.

Discoid roaches provide protein, fats, amino acids and other nutrients that contribute to the diet of insect-eating reptiles. Crickets are nutritious too. The difference isn't that crickets lack nutritional value. It's that discoids offer another good source of nutrition, with practical husbandry advantages.

Research has shown that discoid roaches contain substantial protein, although their exact composition varies with age and feeding conditions.

Neither feeder is nutritionally complete on its own. Gut loading, calcium supplementation, the right feeder size and dietary variety all remain important.

Our philosophy is simple: choose nutritious feeders, keep them well, and offer variety suited to your reptile's species and life stage, and that starts with how we feed our own colonies.

Discoids and crickets at a glance

Crickets Discoid roaches
Protein Good source Good source
Fat Varies by species and life stage Varies by life stage
Calcium Supplementation generally needed Supplementation generally needed
Noise Adult males chirp No chirping
Odor Can become strong without good upkeep Can develop odor too; good husbandry matters
Containment Jump and may escape Can't jump like crickets; a secure lid is still needed
Shipping Can suffer losses in transit Can also suffer losses in transit
Feeding role Useful for variety Useful for variety and routine feeding

The hidden cost of cricket losses

A feeder order should keep its value beyond the moment it arrives.

When crickets are lost in transit, or more die during storage, the purchase price hasn't changed, but the number of usable feeders has. That makes shipping losses and short-term survival worth weighing when you compare feeder options.

Discoid roaches are often a practical choice for keepers who want to hold live feeders between feeding sessions. With appropriate care, they can be a manageable part of your feeding routine.

Live arrival depends on shipping conditions, packaging, weather and handling, and no live feeder is immune to transit stress.

The sound of silence: another reason we prefer discoids

There's something charming about hearing a cricket chirp on a warm Florida evening.

Hearing dozens of them from a feeder container inside your home? That's another story.

Adult male house crickets (Acheta domesticus) produce high-pitched mating calls, typically around 4,500–5,000 Hz. Research has documented calling rates from roughly 40 to 200 chirps per minute, depending on conditions.

For reptile keepers holding multiple adult crickets, that familiar chirping can quickly become an unwelcome soundtrack.

Discoid roaches (Blaberus discoidalis) offer a quieter alternative. They don't produce the repetitive mating chirps associated with house crickets, which makes them especially appealing to keepers who hold feeder insects indoors.

Chirping and noise comparison: house crickets call at about 40 to 200 chirps per minute near 4.5 to 5 kHz; discoid roaches do not produce a repetitive mating chirp

We still appreciate crickets as an occasional addition to a varied reptile diet. But when it comes to everyday feeding, we prefer a little less noise and a lot more simplicity.

Your reptiles need nutritious food. Your home doesn't need a cricket chorus.

Source: Singing Insects of North America, house cricket (Acheta domesticus) calling song, citing Weissman and Gray (2019).

Do we still feed crickets?

Yes, just not as our everyday first choice.

Crickets can add dietary variety and feeding enrichment, and some reptiles respond enthusiastically to their movement. They still have a place in reptile keeping.

For our preferred everyday feeder, though, we lean toward discoid roaches. We appreciate their nutritional value, how manageable they are to keep, and the flexibility they offer when planning a varied feeding routine.

It's not about eliminating crickets. It's about making more informed choices.

Why discoids make sense for Florida reptile keepers

In Florida, choosing a feeder also means knowing which species can legally be kept, moved and sold.

The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services lists the discoid cockroach (Blaberus discoidalis) among commonly permitted feeder arthropods. See Florida-Legal Feeders for the details.

Our feeders are raised in Marion County, Florida, and we serve Florida reptile keepers with a carefully chosen range of live feeders, shipped or picked up locally in Ocala.

A more thoughtful way to feed

We don't believe a larger catalog automatically means a better feeder experience. We believe in offering insects with a purpose, helping customers understand their choices, and making reptile feeding less complicated.

Crickets have their place. Discoid roaches have earned ours.

Explore: Discoid Care & Storage · Feeder Size Guide · Gut Loading Feeder Insects

A quick note on hornworm sizes

Hornworms keep growing the whole time they travel, so the ones in your cup may not look exactly like the photo. We pick them from the small end of the size you order to leave room for that growth. Even so, warm weather or an extra day in the mail can bring them in bigger. Every cup comes with its own food, so they stay fed on the way to you and after they arrive.